Scottish Independence: An introduction

I have been toying with the idea of a blog like this for a while now, and upon some reflection I have decided to put it out there.

This will be the first in a series of posts discussing the ins and outs of Scottish independence. It won’t be focusing on every subject but will take a more legal route towards the big issues where possible.

The reasons for this are simple: I am sick and tired of reading propaganda in the media.

This whole concept will be based on neutrality. Some of it will wildly favour the ‘Yes’ campaign and some of it will favour the ‘No’ campaign, but somewhere in the middle there is a realistic outcome and that is what I shall seek to find in the midst of faux news and publicity.

The simple, but most fundamental thing we need to understand about independence is the one thing that most people struggle with. Independence is not about the SNP, it is not about Alex Salmond and it is certainly not about a little white paper publishing one group’s political manifesto.

Independence is about the Scottish people choosing to Self-Govern.

Many argue we are not capable of such; and many argue that we are.

The first post, after this one, will focus on what or who Scotland is. We pride ourselves as a nation on ‘Scotland the Brave’. We have our own sports teams, our own international identity as people; but does Scotland actually exist in International Law?

This may seem to be a strange place to start, but I feel it is fundamental to the rest of the questions being raised. We must determine who or what Scotland actually is and where it stands as a nation. The rest goes for the rest of the United Kingdom also; for example, does England exist? Is the United Kingdom actually a country………

The list of questions goes on, and I will certainly not be aiming to give a history lesson. I will begin in 1706/7 and quickly work over the Edinburgh agreement, the E.U., the national debt, taxation, Oil, the law of the sea, currency, constitutional framework……..all the really important questions. The ones that actually matter; and not the ones that are politically pleasing i.e.) Will I need a passport to go to England?

The simple thing to remember about independence is that it is not in everyone’s interests; and by that I refer to Politicians.

A Scottish MP (In Westminster) is unlikely to support Independence on the basis that they will be out of a Job. In that case, groups such as Scottish labour are naturally going to be against Independence as their party’s politics are determined from south of the border. It is also clear that Labour cannot wish to become the UK Government without the vote of the Scottish People: so they are bias.

The SNP are clearly bias, but in the other way. My issue with the SNP is that I feel Independence, rather than a selfless act, has become more about Alec Salmonds personal legacy than what is best for the Scottish people.

I could go into every party in detail, but I won’t.

I am hoping to be posting here fairly regularly on the subject, with some boring legal analysis and a few twists and turns on figures but I cannot promise it will be a daily issue. As I say, my main aim is to put out there the facts and some of my own opinion on the main matters of Independence. I can’t say 100% of it will be original work either, the Scottish Government, the House of Lords have all sought their own in depth advice on the matter and published it so naturally I will cover much of the same ground. However, unlike those papers I do not have a particular aim to achieve other than clearing up the ‘facts’ as the problem with much of the legal advice is that it is priority based, and fighting the cause for whomever has sought the advice. Like any debate however, there are always two sides to the argument and it would be easy to be drawn into the argument of one side or the other if you do not analyse the facts, and more importantly the influence behind the facts, that each group provides.

Explore posts in the same categories: Politics

Tags: , , , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

4 Comments on “Scottish Independence: An introduction”

  1. Ian Says:

    Great news. I look forward to your forthcoming posts on a subject with too many vested interests and subject to biased propaganda in the media.

  2. eddie rice Says:

    Looking forward to your mussings on this epic subject Garry.

  3. Joseph Says:

    Yip. I will go along with the above. Look forward to the debate.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: